![]() |
Art in the interview by Denise Nestor--go see and read! |
The “good-enough” standard is not very desirable.
Seek Giacometti’s “The Palace at 4 a.m.” Go back two hours. See towers and curtain walls of matchsticks, marble, marbles, light, cloud at stasis. Walk in. The beggar queen is dreaming on her throne of words… You have arrived at the web home of Marly Youmans, maker of novels, poems, and stories, as well as the occasional fantasy. D. G. Myers: "A writer who has more resolutely stood her ground against the tide of literary fashion would be difficult to name."
![]() |
Art in the interview by Denise Nestor--go see and read! |
Alas, I must once again remind large numbers of Chinese salesmen and other worldwide peddlers that if they fall into the Gulf of Spam, they will be eaten by roaming Balrogs. The rest of you, lovers of grace, poetry, and horses (nod to Yeats--you do not have to be fond of horses), feel free to leave fascinating missives and curious arguments.
Hard to live with yourself if you think you are a genius--and impossible for anybody else to live with you. But "good enough" is not a standard--she's right.
ReplyDeleteWell, she was a wife and is a mother and grandmother, so I expect her illusions were rubbed away fairly quickly. She seems a modest person.
ReplyDeleteI prefer a young woman with those illusions over one with "good enough" illusions. Or no illusions.
And yes, the whole business of put in X hours and you automatically have mastery and Mozart is a bucket of wishful thinking. Though no doubt X hours will improve one's performance a great deal...
I've never read the 10,000 hours thing as a guarantee--more as a baseline. Along the lines that if you want to do something (play cello, write stories, repair heart valves), don't even kid yourself that you'll be any good at it until you've put in at least 10,000 hours.
ReplyDeleteI view it as a reminder (reassuring or depressing, depending upon one's personality) that talent + wanting doesn't = success. Want to whine about how you're not doing well (enough)? Put in your 10,000 hours of practice, and then we'll see.
Definitely drive is absolutely essential. And putting the time in. Agree!
ReplyDeleteI'm wondering if part of the problem with talking about genius is the way the definition has shifted so radically over time. What if we went back to the beginning?
Wikipedia / Etymology[edit source | editbeta]
Main article: Genius (mythology)
In ancient Rome, the genius (plural in Latin genii) was the guiding spirit or tutelary deity of a person, family (gens), or place (genius loci).[2] The noun is related to the Latin verb gigno, genui, genitus, "to bring into being, create, produce." Because the achievements of exceptional individuals seemed to indicate the presence of a particularly powerful genius, by the time of Augustus the word began to acquire its secondary meaning of "inspiration, talent."[3]
I think the old idea of a genius really connects up with that feeling of inspirations flooding in from outside oneself... It connects with ideas of being led, and with the sense that one is sometimes connected with something larger (or becomes larger oneself) when writing.
I have to agree that genius has to do with being inspired by something outside/beyond one's self, transcending the merely single voice of individuality and tapping into something larger.
ReplyDeleteAnd every amazing work of art, it seems to me, does that.
I suppose it's a matter of someone consistently producing amazing works of art.
A person has to believe in herself, but not necessarily think herself a genius to keep at this.
Yes, that seems right as well... Another way of looking at the same thing...
ReplyDeleteI can't say that I really thing about these things. I tend to have a sort of simple view that we are all in the ocean of art together, and that, yes, some are minnows and some are cuttlefish (put that in for Mary B!) and some are great whales. But we all are and together make up the sea.
I would like to have a tutelary deity. Or even just rent one for special occasions.
ReplyDelete(no URL) XD
ReplyDelete